Three small aliphatic cyclic anhydrides account for most of the confusion in the low-molecular-weight anhydride trade: succinic anhydride (108-30-5), maleic anhydride (108-31-6) and glutaric anhydride (108-55-4). They are all five- or six-membered cyclic anhydrides, all sold as white to off-white solids, all described as “aliphatic anhydride” on a quotation, and they do not behave alike at all – one carries a polymerisable double bond, one is three methylenes long, and their melting points span 60 degrees.
Two facts make this the most error-prone corner of the anhydride market. The CAS numbers of succinic and maleic anhydride differ by one digit (108-30-5 against 108-31-6). And a titration for total anhydride, which is what most certificates report as assay, counts all three as anhydride without comment. The result is that a wrong lot can arrive with a passing certificate, and the test that catches it is not chemistry – it is a melting point.
The Three Molecules Side by Side
| Property | Succinic anhydride | Maleic anhydride | Glutaric anhydride |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAS | 108-30-5 | 108-31-6 | 108-55-4 |
| Formula | C4H4O3 | C4H2O3 | C5H6O3 |
| Molecular weight | 100.07 | 98.06 | 114.10 |
| Ring size | Five-membered | Five-membered, unsaturated | Six-membered |
| Methylene chain | -CH2-CH2- | -CH=CH- | -CH2-CH2-CH2- |
| Anhydride group content | 71.97% | 73.45% | 63.12% |
| Melting point | 118-121 deg C | 52-54 deg C | 55-57 deg C |
| Theoretical iodine value | 0 | 258.8 | 0 |
| PubChem CID | 7922 | 7923 | 7940 |
| InChIKey (prefix) | RINCXYDBBGOEEQ | FPYJFEHAWHCUMM | VANNPISTIUFMLH |
Note what the molecular weights do and do not tell you. Maleic anhydride is the lightest of the three and carries the most anhydride per unit mass, so it is the most concentrated hardener – and it is also the one you cannot use as a drop-in, because the double bond reacts with anything that reacts with a double bond. The molecular weight alone would not warn you.
Test 1: Melting Point
Melting point separates all three in a single measurement, needs no reagent and cannot be fooled by a titration:
| Material | Melting point | What a reading tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Succinic anhydride | 118-121 deg C | The high one. A reading below 118 deg C means something lower-melting is present |
| Glutaric anhydride | 55-57 deg C | Distinguishable from maleic anhydride only narrowly – go to iodine value |
| Maleic anhydride | 52-54 deg C | Nearly the same as glutaric; iodine value separates them cleanly |
| Succinic acid (110-15-6) | 182-185 deg C | The diacid, not the anhydride: a hydrolysed lot reads high, not low |
| Maleic acid (110-16-7) | 130-135 deg C | Hydrolysed maleic anhydride, and the pair re-equilibrate on heating |
The table also shows where melting point stops working. Maleic and glutaric anhydride are 3 degrees apart and no capillary reading will separate them reliably; that is what the second test is for. And the direction of the failure matters: a hydrolysed succinic anhydride lot melts higher than specification, not lower, because succinic acid melts at 182 deg C.
Test 2: Iodine Value
Iodine value measures unsaturation, and in this group it is a binary test rather than an analog one: maleic anhydride should read 258.8, the other two should read essentially zero. Anything in between is a blend, and the arithmetic is linear enough to be useful:
| Maleic anhydride blended into succinic anhydride | Iodine value |
|---|---|
| 0% | 0 |
| 1% | 2.59 |
| 5% | 12.9 |
| 10% | 25.9 |
| 100% | 258.8 |
For succinic anhydride the test is free information, because the theoretical value is zero: any reading above a couple of points is either maleic anhydride blended in or an unsaturated impurity, and neither is a specification-compliant lot. For glutaric anhydride the test is what separates it from maleic anhydride in the case where the melting points overlap.
It is worth knowing why maleic anhydride’s titration assay cannot substitute for this. A total-anhydride titration counts an anhydride ring whether or not it carries a double bond, so a 5% maleic blend in succinic anhydride can pass a 99.5% assay and still be a completely different product in an unsaturated polyester kettle.
Test 3: Anhydride Content and the Dose It Predicts
Anhydride group content sets the equivalent weight, and the three differ by more than 10%:
| Anhydride | Anhydride group | Working AEW | Equivalents per kg | phr at EEW 185, r 0.90 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maleic anhydride, 99.5% | 73.45% | 98.6 | 10.15 | 47.9 |
| Succinic anhydride, 99.5% | 71.97% | 100.6 | 9.94 | 48.9 |
| Glutaric anhydride, 99% | 63.12% | 115.3 | 8.68 | 56.1 |
The glutaric step is the meaningful one: 15% more material for the same stoichiometry, because the extra methylene adds mass without adding anhydride. The succinic and maleic doses are within 2% of each other, which is precisely the problem – a maleic-for-succinic mix-up does not show up as a dose error, it shows up as a cured resin with the wrong crosslink density, a yellowing part, or a polyester with an unexpected branch point.
Hydrolysis: What Each One Leaves Behind
All three open with water and none of the diacids re-closes in a warehouse, but the arithmetic differs, and the free acid conversion factor differs with it:
| Anhydride | Diacid formed | At 0.1% water: anhydride lost | Diacid formed | Free acid rise | Free acid % = acid value x |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maleic anhydride | Maleic acid, 116.08 | 5.4 kg/t | 6.4 kg/t | +0.64 points | 0.1034 |
| Succinic anhydride | Succinic acid, 118.09 | 5.6 kg/t | 6.6 kg/t | +0.66 points | 0.1052 |
| Glutaric anhydride | Glutaric acid, 132.11 | 6.3 kg/t | 7.3 kg/t | +0.73 points | 0.1177 |
One property separates maleic anhydride from the other two here, and it is the reason maleic anhydride and maleic acid are usually discussed as a pair: the cis diacid dehydrates back to the anhydride on heating, which is one of the industrial routes to the anhydride. Succinic and glutaric acid do not return so readily, so for those two a hydrolysed lot is a lost lot.
Where Each One Actually Goes
Maleic anhydride is by far the largest volume of the three, and almost none of it is sold as an epoxy hardener. It goes into unsaturated polyester resin, into copolymers, into maleic acid and fumaric acid, into alkyds and into intermediate chemistry where its double bond is the point rather than an impurity.
Succinic anhydride is the ring-opened building block: polyester and alkyd branching, succinate and succinimide intermediates, surface modification of starch and fillers, and co-hardener use in powder and laminating epoxy systems.
Glutaric anhydride is the longest chain of the three and the one used where a six-membered ring and a longer, more flexible segment are wanted: glutarimide and glutarate intermediates, polyester polyols, plasticiser and specialty resin chemistry, and epoxy systems where the extra methylene is there to soften a network that a succinic system would make too brittle.
One naming trap is worth flagging. The succinimide dispersants used in lubricants are made from a polyisobutylene-maleic anhydride adduct, not from succinic anhydride; the “succinic” in the name refers to the succinimide ring that is formed afterwards. Sourcing succinic anhydride on the strength of the word is a common and expensive inference.
The Purchase Order Problem
108-30-5 against 108-31-6. One digit, two products, and no supplier in the chain will necessarily notice. Three habits prevent it:
- Write the name and the CAS on the requisition, and check that they agree with each other. A requisition that says “succinic anhydride, CAS 108-31-6” is self-contradictory and should stop there.
- Ask for melting range and iodine value on the certificate, not assay alone. For succinic anhydride both tests are cheap and both catch the error.
- Test the first drum of every new source. The melting point is thirty minutes of work and it is the last line of defence.
Certificates: What to Ask For
- Melting range, not a single figure – it is the identity test and the blend test at once.
- Iodine value, because it is zero for two of the three and 258.8 for the third, which makes it the cheapest specificity available.
- Assay with its basis, stated as total anhydride by titration, and not relied on alone.
- Free acid or moisture, converted with the factors above – the three differ by 15%.
- Appearance and flowability, since caking means the surface has already hydrolysed.
FAQ
Is succinic anhydride the same as maleic anhydride?
No. Succinic anhydride (108-30-5) is saturated and melts at 118 to 121 deg C; maleic anhydride (108-31-6) has a double bond, melts at 52 to 54 deg C and has a theoretical iodine value of 258.8. The CAS numbers differ by one digit, and both are white solids sold in flake, which is what makes the confusion common.
Can one substitute for the other in an epoxy formulation?
Not safely. The dose happens to be within 2%, so the stoichiometry survives. The chemistry does not: maleic anhydride’s double bond copolymerises, discolours and can Diels-Alder react with dienes in the formulation, and the cured network is different even when the equivalents match.
Why is glutaric anhydride dosed higher?
Because its anhydride content is 63.12% against 71.97% for succinic anhydride. The extra methylene adds mass but no anhydride, so the equivalent weight is 115.3 against 100.6. At EEW 185 and r 0.90 the dose is 56.1 phr against 48.9.
How do I tell maleic from glutaric anhydride when the melting points overlap?
Iodine value. Maleic anhydride reads 258.8 theoretical; glutaric anhydride reads zero. There is no ambiguity in that measurement even though the melting points are three degrees apart.
Does a hydrolysed lot read low on melting point?
No, and this is the counter-intuitive part. Succinic acid melts at 182 to 185 deg C, so a hydrolysed succinic anhydride lot reads high rather than low. That is why the melting point must be interpreted together with free acid or moisture, not on its own.
Are the succinimide lubricant additives made from succinic anhydride?
No. They are made from a polyisobutylene-maleic anhydride adduct; the succinimide ring in the name refers to the structure formed when the adduct reacts with a polyamine, not to the anhydride feedstock.
References and Further Reading
- Succinic anhydride, CAS 108-30-5: C4H4O3, 100.07 g/mol, PubChem CID 7922, InChIKey RINCXYDBBGOEEQ-UHFFFAOYSA-N.
- Maleic anhydride, CAS 108-31-6: C4H2O3, 98.06 g/mol, PubChem CID 7923, InChIKey FPYJFEHAWHCUMM-UHFFFAOYSA-N.
- Glutaric anhydride, CAS 108-55-4: C5H6O3, 114.10 g/mol, PubChem CID 7940, InChIKey VANNPISTIUFMLH-UHFFFAOYSA-N.
- Anhydride basis: C2O3 = 72.02 g/mol, so 72.02 / MW gives the anhydride content and MW / content gives the working equivalent weight.
- Iodine value basis: 253.81 g/mol for I2 and one double bond per molecule; maleic anhydride at 98.06 g/mol gives 258.8, and a 1% blend into a saturated anhydride adds 2.59.
- Hydrolysis basis: one mole of water per mole of anhydride, so 0.1% water (1 kg/t) consumes 1/18.015 kmol of anhydride and forms the same amount of diacid.
- PolyBlueChem: succinic anhydride product page; succinic anhydride: melting point, anhydride content and identity; anhydride dosage in phr.
- PolyBlueChem: alkenylsuccinic anhydrides: chain length, dose and identity – the next step out from the unsubstituted molecule, and where the iodine value becomes the identity test.
- PolyBlueChem: free acid, colour and storage of acid anhydrides; THPA product page.
Contact PolyBlueChem for a current certificate of analysis with melting range and iodine value, a sample for qualification, and a quotation for bag or drum supply.