MTHPA Grades: Crystallisation Point, Viscosity and Colour

Seven Grades Under One CAS Number

MTHPA is bought under a single CAS number, 11070-44-3, and quoted in at least seven specifications that differ in price and in behaviour. The price difference is easy to explain and easy to argue about; the behaviour difference is what the specification is actually buying.

This page is the decision layer between the seven: which number changes what in the plant, what each axis costs when it is wrong, and how to write the three lines that stop a supplier from shipping the grade that was cheapest to make that week. Product data is on the MTHPA product page; the chemistry behind the mixture is in the MTHPA main article.

What All Seven Grades Have in Common

Three numbers barely move across the range. If a quote differs from another quote on these, the difference is quality rather than grade:

Item Common to the range Why it does not differentiate
Anhydride group content 40.5% min or 41.0% min A 0.5 point difference is 1.2% on the equivalent weight, inside most formulation tolerances
Acid value 640 to 685 mg KOH/g The same titration window on every grade; it confirms the anhydride is intact, not which grade it is
Volatiles 1.5% max Identical limit throughout

Four numbers carry the whole difference: crystallisation point, viscosity, colour and free acid. Each one answers a different question, and each one is bought for a different reason.

Axis 1: Crystallisation Point, 0 deg C or -15 deg C

This is the axis that costs money in logistics rather than in the drum. A 0 deg C grade is liquid in a warm plant and solid in a cold one; a -15 deg C grade stays liquid through a northern winter in an unheated store.

The failure is quiet. A drum that has partly crystallised looks fine from the bung, samples as a liquid if the sample is taken from the top, and then delivers a free acid figure and a viscosity that cannot be repeated on the next lot. The crystals and the mother liquor are not the same composition, so a partly crystallised drum is not a homogeneous material until it has been fully melted and mixed.

Three practical tests follow:

  • Buy the -15 deg C grade where the store, the truck or the site can see sub-zero temperatures. The premium is smaller than one winter of heated storage.
  • Buy the 0 deg C grade only with a temperature commitment. That means a store held above 5 deg C and a delivery route that does not park overnight at -10 deg C.
  • Never sample a drum that has been cold. If in doubt, melt it completely in a controlled oven, roll or stir it, and then sample.

The crystallisation point is also the fastest arrival check available, because it needs no titration and no instrument beyond a cooling bath. Two grades that share a CAS, a formula and a molecular weight differ by 15 deg C here, which is the clearest evidence that the CAS number does not define the product.

Axis 2: Viscosity, 30 to 50 or 50 to 70 mPa.s at 25 deg C

Viscosity is bought for the process, not for the cure. The equivalent weight does not change, so the dose does not change, and the cured properties of the two grades are comparable at the same r.

What changes is what happens between mixing and gelation:

  • Impregnation and vacuum casting. The lower band fills fine gaps and releases air more easily. For dry-type transformer and instrument transformer casting, 30 to 50 mPa.s is the practical band.
  • Filled systems. Filler settles according to Stokes’ relation, where the settling velocity is proportional to particle size squared and to the density difference, and inversely proportional to viscosity. Going from 40 to 60 mPa.s cuts the settling velocity by about one third, which is the difference between a drum that needs rolling before use and one that does not.
  • Film thickness and pot life. Higher viscosity changes the working time in a multi-part dispenser and the thickness achieved per pass; both are process settings that have to be re-qualified if the grade changes.

The error to avoid is swapping viscosity grades to fix a cure or a void problem. Voids come from volatiles, moisture and air entrainment far more often than from viscosity, and a cure problem is an equivalent weight problem, not a viscosity one.

Axis 3: Colour, from “Pale Yellow” to Pt-Co 10

Half the grades in the list are described as pale yellow clear liquid with no number at all. That is a description, not a specification, and it cannot be compared between suppliers: one plant’s pale yellow is another plant’s Pt-Co 120.

The graded axis starts at Pt-Co (Hazen) 50 and runs to 10:

Colour figure What it looks like Where it is bought
No number, “pale yellow” Anything from nearly clear to distinctly yellow General casting where the part is not visible
Pt-Co 50 max Light yellow, water-clear body Visible castings, light-coloured potting compounds
Pt-Co 20 or 30 max Nearly water-white Light-coloured parts, the bridge to optical work
Pt-Co 10 max Water-white Optical and optoelectronic encapsulation

Two technical notes. Pt-Co is a visual comparison scale, not a linear absorbance reading, so the step from 20 to 10 is not the same size as the step from 50 to 20 in perceptual terms. And colour in a liquid anhydride is largely an iron story: an unlined carbon-steel drum, a rusty pump or a steel dip tube will move a Pt-Co 20 grade past 50 in a few weeks of storage. Buying colour without specifying the container is buying half a specification.

Axis 4: Free Acid, 0.5% or 0.1 to 0.2%

Free acid records how much of the anhydride has already hydrolysed. For MTHPA the arithmetic is slightly harsher than for the solid grades because the molecule is larger: one kilogram of water per tonne – 0.1% – hydrolyses about 9.2 kg of anhydride and forms about 10.2 kg of the diacid, which is a free acid figure near 1.0 point. The same calculation for THPA gives 0.94, because its molecular weight is smaller.

Read the other way, the numbers are a moisture budget:

Free acid limit Water that corresponds to What it requires
0.5% max About 0.5 kg per tonne Closed drums, reasonable handling
0.2% max About 0.2 kg per tonne Closed drums, dry store, short opening times
0.1% max About 0.1 kg per tonne Closed drums with a dry-air or nitrogen blanket after partial use

The consequence is that a 0.1% grade is not bought at goods-in, it is bought by the handling procedure at the customer site. A drum of 0.1% material that is opened every week for a year in a humid plant will not test at 0.1% in December. If the process genuinely needs 0.1%, the procurement decision includes the nitrogen blanket, the drum size – smaller drums opened more often are worse – and who is allowed to open them.

The hydrolysis mechanics, the titration method and the conversion between free acid and acid value are set out in acid anhydrides: free acid, colour, iron and moisture.

The Decision Table

If the application is Take Because
General electrical casting in a temperature-controlled plant 0 deg C grade, 30 to 50 mPa.s No colour requirement, no sub-zero exposure
Same work but with an unheated store or winter transport -15 deg C grade, 30 to 50 mPa.s Stays liquid; no re-melt, no non-homogeneous drum
Highly filled potting compound -15 deg C grade, 50 to 70 mPa.s Slower filler settling at the same dose
Visible casting or light-coloured potting Pt-Co 50 grade First grade with a colour number rather than a description
Light colour plus lower free acid, not optical Pt-Co 20 or 30, free acid 0.1 or 0.2% Colour and hydrolysis both controlled, without optical pricing
LED or optical encapsulation Pt-Co 20 grade Cured colour is the specification
Optical encapsulation with a tight hydrolysis limit Pt-Co 10 grade, free acid 0.1 or 0.2% Both numbers at the top of the range, supplied under blanket

Three Sentences That Prevent the Wrong Grade

A specification is only as good as the numbers in it. Three lines cover the whole range:

  • Identity: “MTHPA, CAS 11070-44-3, crystallisation point -15 deg C max, viscosity 30 to 50 mPa.s at 25 deg C.” Without the last two clauses the CAS number alone permits any of the seven grades.
  • Colour and hydrolysis: “Colour Pt-Co 20 max, free acid 0.2% max.” If colour is left as “pale yellow”, the cheapest grade that week passes.
  • Packing: “Steel drums with phenolic or epoxy lining, nitrogen blanket on request, isomer ratio declared on the certificate of analysis.” The lining is what protects the colour number.

The dosing side of the grade question is small but real: a 41.0% grade and a 40.5% grade differ by about 1.2% in equivalent weight, so at a fixed phr the difference is under 1.5% of the anhydride. The full calculation, including how a r value is chosen in the first place, is in anhydride curing agent dosage.

What to Ask the Supplier

  • Isomer ratio. The upstream variable behind crystallisation point and viscosity. The grades on this page run at 3-methyl / 4-methyl = 65 +/- 5 / 35 +/- 5, declared by the producer rather than printed on every certificate.
  • Which certification the colour figure comes from. Pt-Co on a liquid is normally measured on the neat liquid; a figure quoted on a diluted sample is not comparable.
  • Drum lining and previous contents. A lined drum that previously carried a darker product is a colour risk.
  • Age of the lot. Free acid climbs with time in the drum regardless of handling, so a 0.1% grade bought from stock that is a year old is a 0.1% grade on paper.
  • Whether the 50 to 70 mPa.s grade is the same isomer ratio. It normally is not, and the difference matters if the formulation was qualified on one of them.

FAQ

Does a higher viscosity grade cure slower?

Not because of the viscosity itself. The cure rate is set by the anhydride and accelerator chemistry and by temperature. A higher-viscosity grade can gel in a different time in a thick section because heat builds and diffuses differently, which is a processing effect rather than a kinetic one.

Can I mix two grades to get an intermediate viscosity?

Physically yes, and it is common practice to blend a 30 to 50 grade with a 50 to 70 grade. The result is an intermediate viscosity with an intermediate crystallisation point, so blending a -15 deg C grade with a 0 deg C grade lands somewhere in between and gives up the winter property that was being paid for.

Why is the -15 deg C grade not always more expensive?

Because the crystallisation point is set by the isomer ratio, and the isomer ratio is set by the isoprene addition step rather than by extra purification. Depending on the plant’s raw material and distillation, either grade can be the volume product of the month. It is a reason to ask for the crystallisation point on every certificate rather than to assume the expensive one is the cold-weather one.

Is a colourless grade also a lower-iron grade?

Usually, but not by definition. Colour is measured on the liquid; iron is a contaminant that may or may not show as colour depending on its form and on the storage time. For an electrical part, ask for iron separately – a Pt-Co 20 grade in a rusty drum can carry more iron than a Pt-Co 50 grade in a lined one.

What happens if I use the 0 deg C grade below zero?

It crystallises, partly or fully. Nothing is chemically damaged and a full re-melt restores the product, but the drum must be melted and homogenised before sampling or use, and every re-melt is heat history that moves colour and free acid in the wrong direction.

Related Reading

Scroll to Top