Three Anhydrides That Look Alike on Paper
1,2,3,6-tetrahydrophthalic anhydride, 3,4,5,6-tetrahydrophthalic anhydride and hexahydrophthalic anhydride are bought by the same people, used in the same epoxy curing process and quoted in the same units, and two of them share a molecular formula exactly. Getting the wrong one is easy, and the failure usually shows up months later as a yellowed casting, a slumping melt line or a part that will not reach its glass transition.
This article is the decision table for the family: what each product actually is, which physical test separates them on arrival, and how to write a purchase specification that cannot be satisfied by the wrong material.
The Comparison Table
| Property | 1,2,3,6-THPA | 3,4,5,6-THPA | HHPA |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAS | 85-43-8 | 2426-02-0 | 85-42-7 |
| Formula | C8H8O3 | C8H8O3 | C8H10O3 |
| Molecular weight | 152.15 | 152.15 | 154.16 |
| Anhydride equivalent weight | 152.15 | 152.15 | 154.16 |
| Ring double bond | One, isolated | One, conjugated with the anhydride | None |
| Melting or crystallisation point | About 100 deg C | 66 to 69 deg C | 34 to 38 deg C (crystallisation) |
| Physical form at 25 deg C | Hard white flake | Soft flake, can fuse in warm stores | Low-melting solid, often handled molten |
| Theoretical iodine value | About 166.8 | About 166.8 | 0 |
| InChIKey | KMOUUZVZFBCRAM-UHFFFAOYSA-N | HMMBJOWWRLZEMI-UHFFFAOYSA-N | MUTGBJKUEZFXGO-UHFFFAOYSA-N |
| phr at EEW 185, r = 0.85 | 69.9 | 69.9 | 70.8 |
| Cured colour under UV and heat | Can yellow (unsaturated ring) | Can yellow (unsaturated ring) | Colour stable |
| Possible later crosslinking | Yes, through the retained double bond | Yes, but the conjugated double bond behaves differently | No |
| Typical leading use | Electrical casting, polyester intermediate | Low-temperature casting, eutectic blends | LED and optical potting, outdoor coatings |
Three facts in that table do most of the work. The two tetrahydrophthalic anhydrides are true isomers, so no assay, no elemental analysis and no equivalent weight can separate them. HHPA differs by two hydrogen atoms, only 2.02 g/mol, so its equivalent weight is within 1.3% of the others and the dose calculation barely moves. And the iodine value separates HHPA from the pair cleanly, but it cannot separate the pair from each other.
How to Tell Them Apart on Arrival
Step 1: melting or crystallisation point
This is the cheapest test and it is decisive within the family. A capillary melting point or, for HHPA, a crystallisation point measured under controlled cooling, places the sample in one of three ranges immediately:
- Near 100 deg C: 1,2,3,6-THPA.
- Between roughly 65 and 72 deg C: 3,4,5,6-THPA.
- Between roughly 34 and 38 deg C: HHPA.
The method matters. A slow ramp on a hot-stage gives a cleaner answer than a fast capillary run, and for HHPA the crystallisation point is the meaningful number because the commercial product is an isomer mixture rather than a pure compound.
Step 2: iodine value
Iodine value splits the family into unsaturated and saturated with no ambiguity: the two tetrahydrophthalic anhydrides read about 167 g I2/100 g if fully unsaturated, and HHPA reads 1.0 or below. It is the one test that catches a customer who has been quietly shipped HHPA where THPA was ordered, or THPA blended into an HHPA lot to cheapen it.
What iodine value cannot do is separate the two tetrahydrophthalic isomers, because both carry exactly one double bond. For that, the melting range or the InChIKey is required.
Step 3: InChIKey, if the application is critical
All three keys are different and all three can be printed on a certificate. In a regulated or safety-critical application, the key is the only statement that is unambiguous about which molecule is in the bag:
| Product | InChIKey |
|---|---|
| 1,2,3,6-THPA | KMOUUZVZFBCRAM-UHFFFAOYSA-N |
| 3,4,5,6-THPA | HMMBJOWWRLZEMI-UHFFFAOYSA-N |
| HHPA | MUTGBJKUEZFXGO-UHFFFAOYSA-N |
What the certificate will not tell you
Assay, colour and free acid are all silent about which member of the family you have. A 99% assay with 20 Hazen and 0.1% free acid can describe any of the three. That is why a purchase specification for this family has to name the CAS number and, ideally, the InChIKey, rather than only quoting the purity envelope.
Which One to Specify
Choose 1,2,3,6-THPA when
- You are casting thick electrical sections and want the highest heat resistance the family offers at the lowest raw-material cost.
- You need the retained double bond for later copolymerisation, epoxidation or crosslinking, for example in an unsaturated polyester or a post-curable epoxy.
- Your plant already runs a melt system at 120 to 130 deg C and flake handling is not a problem.
- The cured part is inside an enclosure, so yellowing is not a visible defect.
Choose 3,4,5,6-THPA when
- You want to avoid a high-temperature melt tank, or you want a shorter melt cycle and less thermal exposure of the anhydride.
- You are building a eutectic blend and need a low-melting component to dissolve the higher-melting one.
- You need a lower mix viscosity at the dosing temperature for impregnation of fine windings.
- You are buying a resin feedstock and the 96% grade is adequate, which makes this the cheapest entry into the family.
Choose HHPA when
- The cured part is white, transparent, optically inspected, or exposed to ultraviolet light, including LED potting, light guides and outdoor coatings.
- The application measures colour drift or yellowness index after ageing.
- You want a liquid-operated one-pack route, in which case HHPA is usually transposed into MHHPA rather than used as a solid.
- The specification includes dielectric loss or shrinkage limits that need the tighter custom grade.
The Blend Question
Blending is routine in this family, and it is chemically sensible because the equivalent weights are within 1.3% of each other: a blend keeps the dose almost unchanged while moving the melting range and the viscosity. Two practical rules apply.
Blend within a specification family, not across a promise. If a customer qualifies a THPA system and receives a THPA/HHPA blend, the dose will look right and the colour will improve, but the heat resistance and the glass transition will drop. That is a quality change disguised as a process improvement.
Record which grade went into the blend. Because the iodine value responds to the blend ratio, a retained sample plus the iodine value is enough to reconstruct what was shipped months later, which is exactly the evidence a dispute needs.
Writing a Specification That Cannot Be Mis-Supplied
- Name the CAS number and the isomer. "Tetrahydrophthalic anhydride" is not a specification; 85-43-8 and 2426-02-0 are two products.
- Add the InChIKey for critical work. It costs the supplier nothing and removes the ambiguity permanently.
- Put a melting or crystallisation range in the specification, with a tolerance narrow enough to catch a substitution. For THPA, 98 to 102 deg C; for 3,4,5,6-THPA, the agreed band below 72 deg C; for HHPA, 34 to 38 deg C.
- Put the iodine value in for HHPA, and consider putting it in for THPA as a check against hydrogenation or blending.
- Specify free acid, ash and iron together where colour or dielectric performance matters, because any one of them alone can look healthy while the trio is not.
- Specify the packing and the transport conditions, because the low-melting members of this family are the ones that arrive fused.
FAQ
Are THPA and HHPA interchangeable in a formulation?
Only after re-checking the cured properties. The dose is nearly identical, so a trial casting will look successful, but the heat resistance, the colour stability and the weathering behaviour differ because one molecule has a double bond and the other does not. Interchange them on the basis of the end-use requirement, not the dose.
Which of the three is the most moisture sensitive?
All three hydrolyse, and sensitivity rises with the amount of molten handling: a low-melting product held as a liquid presents more intimate contact with any water present. The free-acid figure is the practical measure, and it is why packing and melt-tank hygiene matter as much as the certificate.
Does the conjugated double bond make 3,4,5,6-THPA more reactive?
It changes its behaviour in cycloaddition and radical chemistry, and it hydrolyses more readily. In an epoxy cure the anhydride ring is what reacts, so the curing chemistry is close to the other isomer; in polyester and grafting reactions the difference is real.
Why do two products share a molecular formula?
Because they are isomers: the same atoms arranged differently in the same ring system. That is why the family is a classic case where formula and molecular weight prove nothing and the physical constants and identifiers do all the work.
Can I use one specification for all three?
Not without losing control. A specification written as "anhydride assay 99% minimum, colour 50 maximum, free acid 0.2% maximum" can be satisfied by any of the three, which means it does not specify anything.
Related Reading
- THPA: properties, grades and curing
- 3,4,5,6-THPA: the low-melting isomer
- HHPA: iodine value and colour stability
- Anhydride dosage in phr
- MTHPA, the liquid alternative, CAS 11070-44-3
- Nadic anhydride (NA), CAS 826-62-0 – the bridged-ring solid at 162 deg C
- MHHPA, CAS 25550-51-0 – the liquid saturated counterpart
- Free acid, colour and moisture control
- MNA, CAS 25134-21-8 – the bridged ring as a liquid, the third option when a solid will not do
- Alkenylsuccinic anhydrides: chain length, dose and identity – the long-chain branch of the same family
Disclaimer: this article describes commercial specifications and industrial chemistry. It gives no recommendation for a specific application without a trial, and regulatory classifications must be verified by the user.
Contact PolyblueChem for certificates, samples and quotations for any of the three products, individually or as an agreed blend.